[[link removed]]

PORTSIDE CULTURE

‘WHAT THE HELL HAPPENED’ TO TUCKER CARLSON? A NEW BOOK TRIES TO
FIND OUT  
[[link removed]]


 

J. Oliver Conroy
January 24, 2026
The Guardian
[[link removed]]


*
[[link removed]]
*
*
[[link removed]]

_ This is the first in depth, book-length portrait of the well-known
far right wing media personality. _

,

 

_Hated by All the Right People: Tucker Carlson and the Unraveling of
the Conservative Mind_Jason ZengerleCrooked Media ReadsISBN:
9781638932932

Tucker Carlson, the podcaster and former Fox News host, once told a
hostile conservative crowd that rightwing media needed to be more
responsible. In a 2009 speech at the Conservative Political Action
Conference, he argued that publications on the right should hold
themselves to a higher standard.

“This is the hard truth,” Carlson said. “If you create a news
organization whose primary objective is not to deliver accurate news,
you will fail.” Conservatives loved to complain about the New York
Times, he added, when what they really needed was their _own_ New York
Times. The crowd jeered and booed at him.

Carlson’s evolution – from a clubbable conservative journalist who
often criticized the kooks, extremists and blowhards of his own side,
to a cautious Maga fellow-traveler, to an “America first”
firebrand
[[link removed]]
more radical than Donald Trump himself – is the subject of a new
book
[[link removed]],
Hated by All the Right People: Tucker Carlson and the Unraveling of
the Conservative Mind. The reporter Jason Zengerle tries to answer a
question that, he notes, haunts any room where political journalists
today gather: “What the hell happened to Tucker?”

Beside Carlson’s own works of memoir-reportage-polemic, the only
previous book about him is an admiring 2023 biography by the
conservative writer Chadwick Moore, described
[[link removed]]
in a Guardian review as “meld[ing] hagiography to dictation”.
Zengerle’s book, written without Carlson’s cooperation, is
therefore the first to reckon critically with probably the most
interesting, important, compelling and arguably dangerous media
personality of the Trump age.

 
The book comes from Crooked Media Reads, a new publishing imprint
created by former Barack Obama staffers, and Zengerle recently joined
the staff of the liberal New Yorker. But he leaned on Carlson as a
reporting source for many years, he writes, and liked him. Now he sees
in Carlson a grim metaphor. The gap between the “gifted young
writer” he knew in the late 1990s and the “noxious talking head”
of today, he argues, “is the larger story of conservative politics
and conservative media over the last 30 years”.

In 1999, Carlson referred to Trump as “the single most repulsive
person on the planet” – and even more recently continued to say
disparaging things about the president in private, as revealed by the
2021 Dominion lawsuit against Fox, which exposed embarrassing text
messages
[[link removed]]
illustrating the gap between Carlson’s public and private views. Yet
as a Fox News host he came to endorse Trump’s agenda mostly
wholeheartedly.

And since he was forced out of Fox
[[link removed]] in 2023, in disputed
circumstances, he has leaned even further into a nativist,
isolationist, far-right stance – talking up the authoritarian
Russian regime, giving airtime to guests who have been accused of
white nationalism, Holocaust revisionism, antisemitism and
conspiracism, and suggesting that Volodymyr Zelenskyy, the Jewish
president of Ukraine, is “sweaty and ratlike” and “a persecutor
of Christians”.

The book focuses on Carlson’s adult career in TV news, though it
does contain some fascinating biography about his early life. Most of
the broad strokes are well known – Carlson himself has often
discussed his childhood – though Zengerle uncovers some new detail
and depth.

 
Carlson’s father, Dick Carlson, was an orphan from a hardscrabble
and tragedy-filled background who became a pioneering newsman,
diplomat, lobbyist and the director of Voice of America and the
Corporation for Public Broadcasting. (Although Dick probably rubbed
shoulders with the intelligence world, Zengerle is skeptical of a
longstanding rumor that he was a CIA operative.)

 
Dick’s first wife and Tucker’s mother, a bohemian heiress,
abandoned the family when Tucker was young. Years later, when she was
dying in France, Tucker and his brother both declined to visit her; in
her will, she left them each $1. Dick’s second wife, Tucker’s
stepmother, was also an heiress – to the Swanson frozen food fortune
– but a more supportive parent. Carlson was nannied by a former
Korean intelligence officer, addressed as Colonel Kwon, and, as
Michael Wolff has written, lost his virginity at 14 in a visit to a
Nevada brothel arranged by his father.

After time as a class clown at a Swiss boarding school, an Episcopal
prep school, Trinity College, and in Nicaragua – where he traveled
during a summer break as a “wing-tipista” writer hoping to help
the contras fighting the leftwing regime – Carlson entered
Washington journalism. He was passionate about such writers as Hunter
S Thompson, PJ O’Rourke, and Joan Didion, Zengerle says, and eager
to follow his father’s footsteps.

When Carlson joined the fledgling (now defunct) Weekly Standard in
1995, the magazine was the flagship of the hawkish
“neoconservative” wing of the Republican party. He quickly earned
a reputation as a talented writer with a contrarian bent and an eye
for humor and color. Yet he saw early that the future lay in cable
news.

By the time Carlson delivered his provocative 2009 quasi-defense of
the New York Times, however, he was near his career’s “lowest
point”, Zengerle writes. A string of news and talkshow slots (at
CNN, PBS, MSNBC) had flamed out. While Carlson’s friend and former
MSNBC colleague, Rachel Maddow, ascended toward stardom, he had been
reduced to doing [[link removed]] Dancing
With the Stars – and was the first contestant voted off.

The CPAC speech was a calculated effort to build buzz for a new
venture, the Daily Caller, that he hoped might become that
conservative New York Times. It did not. Carlson, who obsessively
tracked the Caller’s web-traffic data, very quickly realized that
people wanted something more like Breitbart: line-crossing,
muckraking, anger-feeding. Over time he began hiring more aggressive
and unscrupulous reporters – including four who were later exposed
as holding neo-Nazi or far-right views. (Carlson has said he was not
aware of their views.)

Carlson was also deeply ashamed over his one-time support for the Iraq
war; he had been initially skeptical of the war, but set aside his
reservations at the urging of pro-war neoconservatives he had believed
to be smarter than himself. “Carlson was one of the first – and
for many years, only – conservative pundits to recant his support
for the Iraq war,” Zengerle writes.

Yet he remained angry at himself for having ignored his gut instincts,
and angry at a conservative establishment he felt had misled him:
“Carlson started to wonder what else these people were wrong about.
And he started to wonder what the people he held in low regard” –
like the rightwing isolationist Pat Buchanan, or Trump – “might be
right about”.

When he joined Fox News [[link removed]]
he was also determined not to repeat the mistakes of his earlier, more
staid and centrist, TV career. This time he would out-Fox Fox. And
although he disliked Trump, he recognized earlier than other pundits
that Trump’s oddball candidacy needed to be taken seriously.

 
His foresight was rewarded: in November 2016, Fox executives anxious
to catch up to Trump gave Carlson his own show, Tucker Carlson
Tonight. By July 2020, it was “the highest-rated program in US
cable-news history”. Trump himself took to calling Carlson, daily,
to give unsolicited feedback about his show. Unlike other Fox
personalities, Carlson tried to maintain some professional distance,
Zengerle writes – sometimes even declining to pick up when the
president of the United States called.

That just made Trump keener. In fact, Zengerle reveals, Carlson
“confided to multiple people” a fear that Trump, or an
intelligence service, was recording these phone calls to use against
him later. But Carlson realized that he did not need to talk directly
to Trump to influence him, when the world’s most enthusiastic and
powerful TV viewer already tuned into his show nightly. He began
writing his show for “an audience of one”.

While Zengerle dissects Carlson’s media career with a shrewd
scalpel, we learn less about him as a person. His alcoholism – he
quit drinking
[[link removed]]
in 2002, after a bottom where he drank two double-screwdrivers with
breakfast – gets only a few sentences. We also learn little about
his relationship with his brother, Buckley (not to be confused with
his son, also Buckley) – an even more unfiltered, even harder-living
Carlson whose profile on the right has been rising in recent months,
and who is said by some to represent the angry pure id
[[link removed]]
of the brothers.

Zengerle’s smart, well-written, and well-reported book also leaves
unanswered three big questions. Unfortunately, these are also the most
burning ones: why exactly was Carlson fired from Fox, in 2023, at the
peak of his power? Will he run for president? And how earnestly does
he hold his increasingly out-there views?

Zengerle isn’t quite sure about the first two. As for the third,
“whether Carlson really believes the awful things that he says,”
he argues, “matters less than that he says them at all”. That
answer rings true, but also feels like a slight cop-out. Perhaps, in
its evasiveness, it is fittingly Carlsonian.

Zengerle’s final moral judgment of Carlson – whose influence,
despite leaving Fox, remains significant – is less ambiguous. He
notes that when Carlson was younger he liked to joke about running
into Joseph Sobran, a conservative writer drummed out of the movement
for alleged racism and antisemitism, muttering to himself at a
Denny’s.

“It is tempting to think that Carlson has … suffered the same fate
as the man he once ridiculed,” Zengerle writes. “Except Carlson is
not sitting in an empty restaurant booth. He has the ears of heads of
state and billionaires. He is selling out basketball arenas and
constantly streaming onto our phones. He has descended into madness,
but he is speaking to millions.”

* Tucker Carlson
[[link removed]]
* right wing media
[[link removed]]
* history of media
[[link removed]]

*
[[link removed]]
*
*
[[link removed]]

 

 

 

INTERPRET THE WORLD AND CHANGE IT

 

 

Submit via web
[[link removed]]

Submit via email
Frequently asked questions
[[link removed]]
Manage subscription
[[link removed]]
Visit portside.org
[[link removed]]

Bluesky [[link removed]]

Facebook [[link removed]]

 



########################################################################

[link removed]

To unsubscribe from the xxxxxx list, click the following link:
[link removed]