When Simon Rosenberg calls this fall “consequential,” he doesn’t just mean another budget fight. He’s talking about a season where Democrats either prove they can fight like hell or get written off as the party of compromise. Stuart Stevens doesn’t mince words either: “Strong and wrong will always beat weak and right.” The through-line? If Democrats don’t show strength, they’ll lose the plot — no matter how good the policy.
Both men come back again and again to the same point: narrative and fight. Trump has a story — as corrosive as it is — and he pounds it daily. Democrats, Stevens and Rosenberg argue, have to stop pretending the job is message discipline or clever slogans. It’s bigger: patriotism versus Putinism, law versus criminality, democracy versus appeasement. As Simon puts it, compromise in a moment like this can look an awful lot like capitulation.
But for all the darkness, there’s urgency and hope. Rosenberg frames it as a “vicious cycle of a failing strongman” — Trump growing weaker, lashing out harder, escalating as he declines. The opportunity, he insists, is to turn that weakness into wins, to prove that the pro-democracy coalition isn’t just resisting but advancing. Stevens adds the kicker: call the other side what it is — evil, dangerous, unpatriotic — and don’t be afraid to make them respond.
Tune in for a conversation that insists we still have every tool to win it.
Watch here
