[To say that Hamas’ attack was a war crime does not excuse or
divert attention from Israel’s history of war crimes, or equate what
Hamas did with what Israel has been doing for 75 years.]
[[link removed]]

ON SOLIDARITY AND WAR CRIMES  
[[link removed]]


 

Daniel Spector
October 15, 2023
Thoughts-letter Substack
[[link removed]]

*
[[link removed]]
*
[[link removed]]
*
*
[[link removed]]

_ To say that Hamas’ attack was a war crime does not excuse or
divert attention from Israel’s history of war crimes, or equate what
Hamas did with what Israel has been doing for 75 years. _

,

 

Over the past 75 years Israel has created a Jewish supremacist state
whose response to any Palestinian resistance — from non-violent
demonstrations to armed actions — has been unmitigated violence.
This is the context within which Hamas’ brutal attack on October 7
unfolded. And true to form, Israel is responding to Hamas’ attack
with unimaginable violence, not against Hamas, but against the people
of Gaza.

Hamas’
[[link removed]] slaughter
of 1,300 Israeli civilians, wounding of 3,621 more, and kidnapping of
more than 130 was a war crime, which occurred in the context of
Israel’s ethnic cleansing of Palestinians but cannot be excused by
it. Killing civilians is wrong. Kidnapping, assaulting, and torturing
civilians is wrong. Killing and kidnapping children and babies is
wrong. Killing _any_ child _any_where, _any_ time,
for _any_ reason, by _any_one, is morally repugnant and criminal.

Israel does all of these things to Palestinian civilians. Between 2000
and 2022, Israel
[[link removed]] killed more than 10,000
Palestinians, including 2,300 children
[[link removed]], more
than 500 of whom were 8 years old or younger. This is ethnic
cleansing. This is genocide. This is a war crime.

Source: Israel-Palestine Timeline
[[link removed]]

To say that Hamas’ attack was a war crime does not excuse or divert
attention from Israel’s history of war crimes, or equate what Hamas
did with what Israel has been doing for 75 years. Hamas’ war crime
stands on its own and must be judged on its own. Israel is
fundamentally and historically — _but not solely_ — responsible
for the unending violence in Israel-Palestine, _and_ Hamas committed
a war crime; Palestinian civilians are the primary victims of
Israel’s unending violence, _and_ killing Israeli civilians is
wrong.

In _Mondoweiss_, Zubayr Alikhan wrote
[[link removed]] that
Hamas’ attack was

targeting and capturing countless colonial settlers, in uniform and
plain-clothes… those targeted were, _are_, colonizers, settlers,
the primary agents, actors, impellers of the colonization and genocide
of Palestine… [T]he resistance targets colonial settlements,
established atop ethnically cleansed and razed Palestinian villages;
it targets colonial settlers that live in stolen Palestinian houses,
on stolen Palestinian land, urinate on our corpses
[[link removed]] and dance
on our graves
[[link removed]]… a colonizer
is a colonizer, in uniform or out.

Israelis live on stolen Palestinian land. Because they live on stolen
land, they are settlers. This applies not only to Israelis living in
West Bank settlements, but also to Israelis living in Tel Aviv,
Bethlehem, and Sderot. That fact alone does not make all Israelis
“the primary agents, actors, impellers of the colonization and
genocide of Palestine.” The primary agents of colonization and
genocide are institutions such as the Jewish National Fund, which owns
much of the stolen land; corporations and banks (foreign and domestic)
that profit from the occupation, from the extraction of natural
resources, and from the captive Palestinian economy; the
military-industrial complex (foreign and domestic), which provides the
weapons and enforces the project; the political class, which
administers the project; the Israel lobby (Zionist organizations,
Israeli government hasbara operations, think tanks, billion-dollar
donor networks, etc.); and the U.S. and other governments that provide
military, diplomatic, political, and economic support for the project.

Non-indigenous people in this country are settlers because we live on
land stolen from native peoples. That is a contingent fact of history.
Capitalism turned stolen land into a commodity for profit and working
people have no choice but to live on it. The 23.7 million people who
work for federal, state, and local governments are not the primary
agents of U.S. imperialism. Neither are the striking UAW workers, or
the 110,000 immigrants living in shelters in New York City, or the 400
members of the Los Angeles Children’s Chorus.

To “target” civilians simply because they live on stolen land, is
to substitute demography and geography for political analysis.

William Shoki and Bruce Baigrie put it well
[[link removed]]:

The notion that true solidarity means refraining from opining on the
methods and tactics of resistance employed by an oppressed group is
ridiculous and ahistorical. To treat solidarity as a posture of
complete deference to an oppressed group is lazy and dehumanizing,
robbing that group of agency and complexity. In this context, it is
ironically orientalist. Palestinians are by no means compelled to take
heed of what outsiders say, but they are no monolithic hivemind
[[link removed]].
Unwavering solidarity with the Palestinian people can be complemented
with deeper support for specific political formations (and implicit
rejection of others).

The Palestinian people have the right to resist their oppressors,
including by violent means. “Palestinians have the right to
self-defense,” Noura Erakat said
[[link removed]], “and
to use force to resist settler colonial occupation—not an
unqualified right, but a right nonetheless.”

“Hamas,” Zvi Bar’el wrote
[[link removed]],
“despite its religious ideology, is seen by the Arab public as an
integral part of the Palestinian national struggle.” Marwah
Bishara noted
[[link removed]]:

Hamas is an Islamist group that has routinely used and is still using
controversial and unsavoury methods to further its agenda. But like
other anti-colonial movements that employed questionable methods, it
is first and foremost, a nationalist movement that long condemned
al-Qaeda and ISIL, and never staged an attack outside historical
Palestine. Unlike al-Qaeda, Hamas has won a majority in parliament in
Gaza’s last legislative elections in 2006, and — after
surviving an American orchestrated coup
[[link removed]] — it has acted
as the de facto government of the besieged strip.

The Palestinian people have the right to self-determination, which the
United Nations defines
[[link removed]] as the “right of
people to determine, with no compulsion or coercion, their own future,
political status and independence.” That right is inherent, and
nothing that individual Palestinians or groups of Palestinians do can
justify denying that right to the Palestinian people. Just as nothing
that Israelis or groups of Israelis do can justify denying that right
to the Israeli people.

But saying that both peoples have the right to self-determination is
not enough, because Israelis have that right and Palestinians do not.
Zionism’s concept of the Jewish state is predicated on the belief
that Israeli self-determination requires denying Palestinians that
right, that Jews can be safe only by making Palestinians unsafe. In
the words of Israel’s 2018 Basic Law
[[link removed]]:
“The right to exercise national self-determination
[[link removed]] in the
State of Israel is unique to the Jewish people.”

Israel was brutalizing Palestinians before Hamas was formed in the
late 1980s — from the Nakba in 1948 through the military occupation
of the West Bank, Gaza, and East Jerusalem in 1967 — and continuing
through the siege of Gaza since 2006, when Hamas came to power. In an
article analyzing current events in Israel-Palestine, Haidar
Eid quoted
[[link removed]] Paulo
Freire:

With the establishment of a relationship of oppression, violence has
already begun. Never in history has violence been initiated by the
oppressed. How could they be the initiators, if they themselves are
the result of violence? … There would be no oppressed had there been
no prior situation of violence to establish their subjugation.
Violence is initiated by those who oppress, who exploit, who fail to
recognize others as people — not by those who are oppressed,
exploited, and unrecognized.

Nothing that Hamas does can justify Israel’s violence against the
Palestinian people. “Israel and her allies have to find a way to
crush Hamas — and to make peace with the Palestinians,” wrote
[[link removed]] _Jewish
Forward_ editor-in-chief Jodi Rudoren. And she is getting her wish
— at least the crushing part. Israeli Defense Minister Yoav
Gallant ordered
[[link removed]] “a
full siege on the Gaza Strip. No power, no food, no gas, everything is
closed. We are fighting human animals and we act accordingly.”
Israel has been bombing Gaza continuously since shortly after the
Hamas attack, including with the use
[[link removed]] of
white phosphorus weapons. As of October 14, Israel
[[link removed]] had
killed 2,228 Palestinians in Gaza and wounded 8,744. Entire families
are being obliterated. With the threat of invasion by Israel, tens of
thousands of Palestinians are trying to flee northern Gaza to find
refuge in southern Gaza, on top of the 423,378 whom Israel had
displaced by October 12.

[[link removed]]

Source: DCI-Palestine
[[link removed]]

Apparently, that carnage is not enough. “Hamas wanted a change and
it will get one. What was in Gaza will no longer be,” Gallant said
[[link removed]],
“We started the offensive from the air, later on we will also come
from the ground. We've been controlling the area since Day 2 and we
are on the offensive. It will only intensify.”

According to Gideon Sa’ar
[[link removed]],
a minister in Israel’s war cabinet, Gaza “must be smaller at the
end of the war. We must make the end of our campaign clear to everyone
around us. Whoever starts a war against Israel must lose territory.”

From Israeli President Isaac Herzog
[[link removed]]:
“It’s an entire nation out there that is responsible. This
rhetoric about civilians were not aware, were not involved — it’s
absolutely not true. They could have risen up, they could have fought
against that evil regime.” There are no innocent people in Gaza.

This is Israeli officials saying clearly that their intention is
genocide and ethnic cleansing. And Joe Biden and the West are cheering
them on.

In a military invasion of Gaza, Israel will kill thousands of
Palestinians, wound untold thousands more, displace hundreds of
thousands, and destroy what is left of Gaza’s fragile
infrastructure. Collective punishment of Gaza’s 2.4 million people
in the name of revenge.

President Biden says Israel has the right to defend itself. How is
Israel defending itself by depriving 2 million people of electricity,
water, food, and fuel? How is Israel defending itself by killing and
wounding thousands of Palestinians who had nothing to do with Hamas’
attack? How is Israel defending itself by exploding white phosphorus
shells over Gaza City? And why don’t the Palestinians have a right
to defend themselves?

And what happens after? How would the extermination of Palestinians
and the devastation of Gaza make Palestinians more receptive to peace?
As Palestinians have made clear for the past 75 years, Israel’s
violence will not deter Palestinian resistance because an oppressed
people will never abide their oppression. If Israel “crushes”
Hamas, Palestinians will create another mechanism of resistance.
Israel can’t choose its enemies among the Palestinian people, it can
only create them.

If Hamas had infiltrated Israel and only attacked Israeli military
targets and killed, wounded, and captured only Israeli soldiers,
Israel would still bomb Gaza. If Hamas had infiltrated Israel and only
attacked Israeli military targets and not killed, wounded, or captured
Israeli soldiers, Israel would still bomb Gaza. If Hamas had
infiltrated Israel, attacked Israeli military targets and killed,
wounded and captured Israeli soldiers, and infiltrated Israeli towns
but not attacked civilians, Israel would still bomb Gaza. If Hamas had
infiltrated Israel and killed _one_ Israeli civilian, Israel would
still bomb Gaza. Under any possible scenario of Hamas’ attack,
Israel would still bomb Gaza, because Hamas did the unforgivable —
it brought the fight into Israel; it shattered Israelis’ sense of
immunity, their belief that what their state is doing to Palestinians
is not their problem.

Israel subjects Palestinians to the daily physical, emotional,
psychological, and economic violence of military occupation and siege,
punctuated by episodes of concentrated, horrific violence, especially
in Gaza. Palestinian lives don’t matter. Defense Minister Gallant
called Hamas fighters “human animals,” but Israel treats all
Palestinians as such.

Until last weekend, Israel thought that it could keep a lid on
Palestinian resistance by “mowing the lawn” when necessary.
Hamas’ brutal assault changed that calculus. As Haidar Eid pointed
out
[[link removed]],
Hamas “dared to do the ‘unthinkable,’ i.e., return, not as
visitors granted permission by the coloniser but as liberators
upholding their right to their ancestral land.”

To those who rejoice at or dismiss the murder of Israeli and
Palestinian civilians, I say: We have to have hearts big enough to
hold _all_ of the suffering, and minds clear enough to understand
how to make the suffering stop. To those filled with rage and despair
in this moment, and especially to my Jewish brothers and sisters, I
offer this prayer by Rabbi Alissa Wise.

May the One Who Remembers allow us to hold in one hand 75 years of
occupation, dispossession and violence, and in the other a future of
peace, justice and freedom;

May the One Who is Slow to Anger soften our hearts and our fists,
helping us to put down the sword even at the height of the arc of our
rage;

May the One of Possibility remind us that a future of peace with
justice is possible;

May the One Who Awakens Us to Life hold us in our pain and
vindictiveness until we set those down for the sake of life;

May the One Who Endures allow us to act for the sake of the coming
generations;

May the One Who is Without Limit expand our senses of what is possible
as we reach for justice, freedom and peace for us all.

Amen.

* Self-determination
[[link removed]]
* zionism
[[link removed]]
* Israel-Palestine
[[link removed]]
* Hamas
[[link removed]]
* Gaza
[[link removed]]

*
[[link removed]]
*
[[link removed]]
*
*
[[link removed]]

 

 

 

INTERPRET THE WORLD AND CHANGE IT

 

 

Submit via web
[[link removed]]

Submit via email
Frequently asked questions
[[link removed]]

Manage subscription
[[link removed]]

Visit xxxxxx.org
[[link removed]]

Twitter [[link removed]]

Facebook [[link removed]]

 




[link removed]

To unsubscribe, click the following link:
[link removed]